Talk:Seitokai no Ichizon

From Baka-Tsuki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Seems like this project is heavily touched everywhere. Kira, finish your translation already :/

Now I feel like doing the kiss scene and confession scene from Minatsu <3 --larethian 16:48, 21 October 2011 (CDT)

Standardization[edit]

It bothers me to have different namespace for each volume. We need to standardize this. And before I make further changes, I propose to use Seitokai Series as the project namespace. --larethian 22:48, 26 October 2011 (CDT)

Plot Progression[edit]

I was just wondering if this novel has much plot progression or character development. I watched the whole anime series and in the end not much happened at all :P --Arctosa 02:07, 4 January 2012 (CST)

There's very little plot, it only happens in after volume 6, and only in the prologues and epilogues and the after/extra chapters. The plot mostly revolves around romance side. There is quite a bit of character development, and most of them are either in flashbacks in the interlude chapters, in the unnumbered chapters, or together with plot in the prologues and epilogues. In any case, if a chapter is numbered, it has virtually no plot and only occasional character development through the interactions of the characters. The meat of the character development and plot take place in un-numbered chapters, however a reader can gain insight into the personality and thought process of a character through their banter at times in numbered chapters. This is a gag series which focuses on manzai antics, where more than 80% of them have references woven into them. The references can range from, manga, anime, galge, their respective companies, other light novels, publishers, seiyuus, etc, practically every bit of otaku culture, and from both old school and new. So it can be quite hard to laugh if you don't get most of the references. The definite thing is that, if a chapter is numbered, you can be assured that there is no plot progression in it. --larethian 02:39, 4 January 2012 (CST)

Project resuming[edit]

Another translator has picked the project up at NanoDesu, having currently released 2 chapters, and Haraguro Scanlations has released the last chapter of the last volume of the spin-off.--Kemm (talk)