Suggestions, Requests, and Feedback

[larethian]

Use this unified thread to make requests, suggestions and give feedback for the projects in this subforum.

======

I actually want to ask Big Boss to take HnA out and put it in its own subforum, then merge AW with SAO. But before I include that into my list of requests, anyone, especially staff, has any objections?

(I'll post a list of consolidated requests at a later time in the admin forum, before actually PM-ing him).

[BeginnerXP]

Agreed, AW is from the same author after all.

[Khaleel]

No objections, ma'am.

But, HnA will divide a subforum with another series? I think some series deserve a subforum...

[Misogi]

No objections at all.

[Mystes]

No objections, sir.

Corrected lol

Maybe we could have Campione with HnA?

[ben1234]

Is there a reason why we have a split forum for Haruka?

[Mystes]

Is there a reason why we have a split forum for Haruka?

To be honest, it should go to where PuiPui is. But I guess that Haruka is a patrimonial project that has been created in the early days of BT.

[Khaleel]

No objections, sir.

Corrected lol

Maybe we could have Campione with HnA?

Seriously? Don't mess with my feelings head, Quira.

Edit: [After rereding Larethian plans] Oh damn...Why?

[larethian]

Suggestion

Since this project is very popular and has high amount of ongoing discussion, I suggest to create Volume threads. Each volume thread will be focused on discussion regarding that volume and can reference content in previous volumes. This way, we can minimize spoilers for 'newcomers'. While the spoiler policy is lax here, use spoiler tags (with indication as to what kind of spoiler) whenever necessary to show consideration to others. Spoiler tags are powerful because open spoilers kill participation from people who are adverse to spoilers since they completely avoid the threads(or even forum). I also propose setting up polls for each volume.

[stellarroze]

Suggestion

Since this project is very popular and has high amount of ongoing discussion, I suggest to create Volume threads. Each volume thread will be focused on discussion regarding that volume and can reference content in previous volumes. This way, we can minimize spoilers for 'newcomers'. While the spoiler policy is lax here, use spoiler tags (with indication as to what kind of spoiler) whenever necessary to show consideration to others. Spoiler tags are powerful because open spoilers kill participation from people who are adverse to spoilers since they completely avoid the threads(or even forum). I also propose setting up polls for each volume.

Good idea. I liked what you done with the Itsuten volumes. I also agree that we should combine SAO and AW.

[Tap]

Wouldn't it scatter discussion too far apart?
I don't really think there's much to talk about, for each individual volume...

[M.A.D]

How about separate threads for different arcs? We'll have Aincrad arc, AlfHeim arc, GGO arc, Zekkai arc, and now Alicization arc. Or maybe, separate threads for different games. That way we can put Zekkai's arc into the AlfHeim Online thread.

[BeginnerXP]

Zekken aka. Mother's Rosario is just a big side story, not an arc, Rondo is just as big.

While I don't think we really need separate thread for each volume, separate thread for each of 4 main arcs is good idea, and maybe extra thread to discuss the content not yet translated into English, as currently those who wants to know spoiler of Alicization have to go to animesuki forums, we might be able to make them stay to discuss here with that separate thread too.