cloud wrote:
0). Should the Wiki Project Creator ensure there's a forum feedback thread?
- Yes (Mandatory). If a forum feedback thread doesn't exist, they're required to create one. --- (12) Misogi, Chancs, Cloudii, Devenk, SoulTranslator, Yoyoyo5678, Darklor, Kira082, Victorrama, Bicube, Rydenius, Chaoticrun
- No (Optional). However, recommend that they create one. --- (2) Vallor, Cthaeh
- No. Don't give any mention to forum feedback threads in Project Startup Guidelines. --- (0)
1). About the Future Project Suggestion Poll in these rules...
- Should be kept in the startup rules and MANDATORY --- (2) Chancs, Kira082
- Should be kept in the startup rules and OPTIONAL (current) --- (0)
- Should be removed from the startup rules (FPS will still exist on forums, though). --- (11) Cloudii, Misogi, Victorrama, SoulTranslator, Yoyoyo5678, Vallor, Darklor, Bicube, Cthaeh, Rydenius, Chaoticrun
2). Should there only be one feedback-related forum thread for a project, at a time? If yes, vote on the best way to maintain this.
- Yes, lock old threads --- (1.5) Vallor, Rydenius/2
- Yes, have only one thread and keep moving it (merge posts for any extra threads accidentally created)--- (11.5) Cloudii, Misogi, Chancs, Victorrama, Devenk, SoulTranslator, Yoyoyo5678, Kira082, Bicube, Cthaeh, Rydenius/2, Chaoticrun
- No. Keep the feedback threads separate and keep them unlocked. --- (0)
3). If you said "B" to Question 2, what should we do about the poll questions?
4). What should be the minimum requirements for full project approval? You must give a concrete number of chapters/pages/percentage.
- 1 volume OR 1 chapter +activity --- (1) Darklor
- 1 volume ONLY --- (6) Victorrama, Cloudii, Chancs, Cthaeh, Kira082, Bicube
- 1 volume (approximately), but lower in special circumstances --- (8) Misogi, Devenk83, Yoyoyo5678, Vallor, SoulTranslator, Rydenius, Chaoticrun
5). If the ONE VOLUME requirement gets voted in, what should we do about current series with less than one volume on the sidebar?.
- Keep them on as Full Projects --- (0)
- Re-categorize all of them as Teasers (remove from sidebar) --- (3) Devenk83, Vallor, Cthaeh
- Re-categorize only the inactive ones, but leave the active ones on the sidebar (give active TL a chance) ---- (7.5) Yoyoyo5678, Kira082, Bicube, Chancs, Cloudii, SoulTranslator, Rydenius/2, Victorrama
- Re-categorize their category tags, but keep them on the sidebar --- (1.5) Darklor, Rydenius/2
^Updated.
Darklor wrote:Hm, its just for me that the wording of this choice would mean for me that there should be only one thread as long as they are teasers... - if that isnt the case I would take that choice too...as long as the project poll would reflect the project status.
The wording of this poll isn't really being carried over to the rules. I only asked the mini-polls to get an idea of what people wanted, so it could be reflected in the Wiki rules. Currently, the Wiki rules only state that the Creator should make the Teaser Feedback Thread only if the Future Project Suggestion Thread does not exist. It says nothing about forbidding extra threads or anything (if anything, that would be forum rules, not Wiki rules).
Darklor wrote:Is it really like that? At my time nearly no one did visit the teasers...
And what I meant is: give those already in the sidebar the teaser tag and for the hopeful readers a warning on the project page that those projects are now considered teasers under the new full project rules.
XD Yup, I interpreted you correctly. I even gave everyone a new option with your suggestion on the poll. :3
Though I should mention, I really liked Rydenius's suggestion to move the link to Teaser's right next to the full project list, so it's even easier to click on. But then again, that's again DarkoNeko's domain, so all I can do is pass the suggestion to him..
KuroiHikari wrote:A small thing, but could we drop the mention of raws and just say you're expected to submit a translated excerpt.
Done. Minor change, so I don't think anyone will take issue with it.
@Rydenius:
Also minor changes, so I've corrected those items on the Wiki.
chaoticrun wrote:If the One Volume rules gets voted in, what if, for example:
- There are 2 chapters translated at Volume 1, out of 4. And,
- There are 2 chapters translated too at Volume 2, out of 4.
Is that counted as 1 Volume translated?
No. Under this system, it's not. However, I added an option to the votes in case that's what you want (1 volume's worth of chapters).
EDIT: Actually, removed that vote option. xD
------
Furthermore, the vote majority for question #4 have shifted to "volume volume w/ special exceptions".
As such, the
wiki rules now reflect that change. I've displayed it as a compromise so the one volume looks like the main rule, but there's a mini-disclaimer saying it may be lower.